PINS (PINS Advantage) is a well-built, self-service COI tracking platform aimed at construction and public-agency teams, with native Procore and Viewpoint Vista integrations. Its weak spot for a buyer is the buying process: pricing is quoted by annual COI volume and gated behind a form. Here is an honest comparison, and a free plan you can test on your own certificate in five minutes.
Last updated July 2026
Upload your certificates of insurance
Drop files here or click to upload
Up to 50 files
Uploading...
Facts drawn from pinsadvantage.com product and pricing pages, verified July 2026. Performance figures in the last row are PINS marketing claims, not audited numbers.
| Factor | PINS Advantage | COISoftware |
|---|---|---|
| Primary focus | COI tracking for high-volume vendor and subcontractor programs | COI tracking and verification for teams of any size |
| Service model | Self-service: your team sets requirements and makes final compliance decisions | Self-service: same model, your rules, your decisions |
| Certificate reading | AI-assisted review with stated evidence and reasoning, plus OCR in the agent portal | AI extraction built for ACORD forms, including scans and phone photos |
| Endorsement checking | Flags missing endorsements and incorrect additional insured wording | Checks additional insured, primary and non-contributory, waiver of subrogation and completed operations against your rules |
| Vendor submission | Secure link, no vendor login required | Secure upload link, no vendor account required |
| Construction integrations | Native Procore and Viewpoint Vista, plus an open API | Works alongside Procore and accounting systems; API on higher plans |
| Agent and broker portal | Dedicated agent portal for brokers to submit and manage certificates | Agents submit through the same secure link as vendors |
| Pricing | Quote only. Model published as annual COI and contract volume bands (under 100, 100 to 250, 250 to 500, 500 to 1,000, 1,000 to 2,000, 2,000-plus). No dollar figures on the site. | Published: Starter $49/mo ($24/mo billed yearly), Plus $149/mo ($74/mo billed yearly) |
| Free plan | Not offered; evaluation is by demo | Yes, free tier with no card required |
| Target market | General contractors, public agencies, property managers, insurance agencies, airports | Any industry: construction, property management, healthcare, hospitality, logistics, franchising, public sector |
| Third-party reviews | Listed on G2 and Capterra with public reviews | Not yet listed on the major review directories |
| Best fit | Construction and public-sector programs that need certificate status inside Procore or Vista | Teams that want to see the price, start free and cover any vendor type |
PINS does not publish dollar prices. The volume bands above are quoted from its own pricing page as of July 2026; the dollar figure is only available by contacting them, and you should get it in writing before comparing. The 80 percent compliance in 60 days, 90 percent time reduction and 5 to 15 percent premium reduction figures that appear on PINS marketing pages are the company's own claims and are not independently audited. Reconfirm anything on this page before it drives a purchase decision.
PINS is a credible product. The teams who come to us shopping against it almost always raise the same four things, and none of them are about whether the software works.
PINS publishes its pricing model but not its prices. The pricing page asks for a work email and routes you to a rep. You pick an annual COI and contract volume band, then wait for a number. If you are trying to size a budget this afternoon, that is a full sales cycle in the way.
The published bands run from under 100 certificates a year up to 2,000 and above. Volume pricing is fair at scale, but it means a busy season or a growth year can quietly move you into the next band, and you cannot model that in advance without the dollar figures.
The evaluation path is a scheduled demo, not an upload. You see the product driven by someone who knows it, on certificates chosen to go well, rather than watching it read the ugly scanned ACORD 25 that has been sitting in your inbox for a week.
Procore, Viewpoint Vista, general contractors, airports, public agencies. That focus is a strength if you are in those markets. If you are a property manager, a healthcare system, a franchisor or a staffing agency, more of the platform is shaped around a workflow that is not yours.
To be clear about what PINS is not: it is not a managed service. PINS says plainly that your team sets the requirements, reviews the flagged issues and makes every final compliance decision, which is the same self-service model we run. So this is not the usual software-versus-outsourcing argument. If that is the comparison you actually need, COI tracking software vs managed service covers it, and how to choose COI tracking software walks through scoping the buy before you sit through demos.
The same self-service philosophy, with the price on the page and a free tier, so you can prove the AI on your own worst certificate before anyone books a call.
Starter and Plus prices are printed on the pricing page with monthly and annual figures. You can budget the year before you speak to a human, and nothing about your volume changes the number mid-contract without you seeing it first.
The AI reads an ACORD 25 as a document it understands: insurer and NAIC number, policy numbers, coverage types, per-occurrence and aggregate limits, effective and expiration dates, and additional insured status, from phone photos and faxed scans as well as clean PDFs.
Set your minimum limits and required endorsements once. Every certificate comes back compliant, expiring or non-compliant with the specific reason, so a coordinator can act on it without re-reading the form.
Additional insured, primary and non-contributory, waiver of subrogation and completed operations wording get checked against your requirements rather than filed as attachments nobody opens.
Reminders go to the vendor and the agent at 60, 30 and 15 days before expiration, and stop the moment a compliant replacement certificate lands.
The requirement templates cover construction, property management, healthcare, hospitality, logistics, franchising and public sector, so you are not bending a construction workflow around a hospital vendor list.
If your compliance program lives inside a construction stack, look hard at the integration question first, because that is where PINS is genuinely strong. Our COI tracking for Procore page is honest about how we work alongside Procore rather than inside it. For everyone else, vendor insurance compliance software is the general-purpose page, subcontractor COI tracking for contractors covers construction, and best COI tracking software compares eleven platforms side by side, including this one.
Four steps that will tell you which of these two fits, and they take about an afternoon.
If your subcontractor compliance genuinely runs through Procore or Viewpoint Vista and you need certificate status to live inside that system, PINS has native integrations there and that may end the evaluation. Write down what breaks if the two systems stay separate.
Tip: Ask both vendors what specifically syncs: vendor records only, or compliance status and expiration dates too. The answer usually changes the decision.
Submit the form, pick your annual COI and contract volume band, and get the number in writing. Then compare it against a published monthly plan. You cannot run this comparison honestly without asking, because PINS does not print prices.
Pick one real, messy certificate from your files, ideally a scan with an umbrella layer and a blanket additional insured endorsement referenced in the description of operations. Upload it to a free plan and ask PINS to run the same one live in the demo.
PINS names general contractors, public agencies, property managers, insurance agencies and airports. If you are outside those, look closely at whether the requirement templates and reporting match your vendor mix or need to be rebuilt.
Four cases where we would tell you to buy PINS, and one where we would not.
This is the strongest reason to choose PINS and it is not close. Native integrations with Procore and Viewpoint Vista mean subcontractor and certificate data moves between the systems your project teams already live in. We work alongside Procore rather than inside it. If a project manager needs to see compliance status without leaving Procore, that difference matters more than anything else on this page.
PINS runs a dedicated agent portal built for insurance agencies to submit and manage certificates on behalf of their clients. If your certificates arrive mostly from a handful of brokers rather than directly from vendors, a portal designed around the agent workflow is a real advantage over a general upload link.
PINS names Denver International Airport and the City of Oceanside among its customers and markets specifically to public agencies and airports. Public-sector procurement rewards demonstrable track record with comparable entities, and that reference list is a genuine asset in an RFP process.
PINS is listed on G2 and Capterra with published reviews. We are not yet, and that is a fair thing to hold against us. If independent reviews from verified buyers are part of your diligence, PINS gives you something to read and we currently do not.
If you want to know the price today, test the AI on your own scanned certificate this afternoon, and start without a demo call, that is the trade we make. Published plans, a free tier, and requirement templates that are not shaped around one vertical. Upload the worst certificate you own and judge the result.
PINS Advantage is certificate of insurance tracking software headquartered in Dubuque, Iowa. It collects COIs through secure vendor links, uses AI-assisted review to flag missing endorsements and coverage gaps, tracks expiration dates, automates renewal requests and keeps a timestamped audit history. It markets primarily to general contractors, public agencies, property managers, insurance agencies and airports.
PINS does not publish dollar prices. Its pricing page states that pricing is set by annual COI and contract volume, with bands for under 100, 100 to 250, 250 to 500, 500 to 1,000, 1,000 to 2,000 and 2,000 or more, and asks for a work email to send a quote. Third-party directories list estimates, but the only reliable number is the one PINS gives you in writing.
PINS does not advertise a free plan or a self-serve free trial on its site. The stated evaluation path is a scheduled demo. If testing the AI on your own certificates before committing is important to you, that is the main practical difference between PINS and a tool with a free tier you can sign up for directly.
PINS names native integrations with Procore and Viewpoint Vista, along with an open API for custom connections. That construction-stack coverage is its clearest technical advantage over most COI trackers, and it is the first thing to check if your subcontractor compliance already runs through either of those systems.
It depends on why you are looking. If you need native Procore or Vista integration, PINS is hard to replace and you should probably buy it. If you want published pricing, a free tier to test on your own certificates, and requirement templates that fit an industry other than construction, COISoftware covers the same self-service COI workflow with the price on the page.
No. PINS is explicit that its software assists but your team sets the requirements, reviews flagged issues and makes every final compliance decision. It positions itself against full-service outsourced COI tracking rather than offering it. That makes PINS and COISoftware the same category of product, which is why the comparison comes down to pricing transparency, integrations and industry fit rather than service model.
Choose PINS if your certificates need to live inside Procore or Viewpoint Vista, if brokers submit most of your COIs and would use a dedicated agent portal, or if public-sector references and published third-party reviews carry weight in your process. Choose COISoftware if you want a price you can read today, a free tier to test the AI on your own scanned certificate, and a workflow that is not shaped around construction.
