The best COI tracking software and certificate of insurance tracking companies collect certificates from your vendors, read the ACORD 25, verify coverage against your requirements, and warn you before a policy expires. Below we compare twelve leading platforms (COISoftware, myCOI, Certificial, TrustLayer, SmartCompliance, Jones, BCS, CertFocus, Evident, Avetta, PINS Advantage and Compliance Depot) on what they do, who they fit, and how they price, so you can pick the right one. Upload a certificate above to try the AI extraction yourself.
Last updated July 2026
Upload your certificates of insurance
Drop files here or click to upload
Up to 50 files
Uploading...
Ten of the most established certificate of insurance tracking platforms, what each is best at, and how it prices.
| Software | Best for | Pricing model | Standout strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| COISoftware | Teams that want AI extraction and transparent pricing | Free tier plus transparent monthly plans | AI ACORD 25 extraction, no per-vendor minimums |
| myCOI (now illumend) | Mid-market teams wanting a managed, done-for-you service | Custom quote | Managed insurance expert team plus the Lumie AI engine |
| Certificial | Teams that want real-time policy monitoring | Custom quote | Live agency-management-system data, no vendor login |
| TrustLayer | Tracking COIs alongside other compliance documents | Custom quote | Tracks COIs with W-9s, licenses and contracts |
| CertFocus | Enterprises wanting credentialed insurance staff on review | Published: $6 to $8 per vendor per year self service, $7,500 annual minimum | The only major platform that publishes per-vendor pricing |
| SmartCompliance | Larger enterprise compliance programs | Custom quote | Full-service and self-service options for high volume |
| Jones | Real estate and property management teams | Custom quote | Vendor-friendly workflow with no vendor login |
| BCS (Business Credentialing Services) | Construction and real estate programs wanting analysts to own the work | Custom quote, per vendor or tenant, free trial offered | Full-service team per account, plus RFP and vendor sourcing workflow |
| Evident (EvidentID) | Enterprises wanting insurance verification inside full vendor due diligence | Published: $15 per vendor per year Essential, $25 Pro, Enterprise custom | Background checks, MVR and credential verification alongside COIs |
| Avetta | Large supply chains needing full contractor prequalification, not just COI tracking | Contractor pays roughly $450 to $900 per year, client pays separate enterprise fee | Prequalification network with a certified insurance monitoring team |
| PINS Advantage | Construction and public agency programs that need compliance status inside Procore or Viewpoint Vista | Quote only, priced by annual COI and contract volume band | Native Procore and Viewpoint Vista integrations plus a dedicated agent portal |
Positioning is summarized from public 2026 sources and vendor websites. CertFocus pricing is published by its parent company, Vertikal RMS. Avetta is a contractor prequalification platform where insurance verification is one module and the contractor pays to join the network; its pricing is drawn from third-party 2026 write-ups and varies by tier. Most other competitors quote custom pricing rather than publishing flat rates, so confirm current pricing and features directly with each vendor. Last verified July 2026.
Before comparing brands, it helps to remember what you are trying to fix. Manual certificate tracking fails in the same predictable ways.
A spreadsheet does not email anyone. A vendor's policy expires mid-project and the work continues uninsured until something goes wrong.
Filing a certificate is not the same as checking it. Limits below your requirement or a missing endorsement slip through when nobody reads every line.
Retyping limits, dates and policy numbers off each certificate guarantees mistakes, and one typo makes your compliance record wrong.
When a client, insurer or lawyer asks for proof, you dig through folders and inboxes instead of pulling one clean report.
Following up by email to collect renewals eats hours every week and still leaves gaps in coverage.
Certificates live in email, desktops and filing cabinets, so nobody can answer "who is compliant right now?" in one click.
The cost of a lapsed or insufficient certificate is rarely the software you skipped. It is the uncovered claim, the contractual penalty, or the workers compensation audit that reclassifies an uninsured subcontractor as your own payroll. The right COI tracking software closes that gap and gives your team back the hours spent typing and chasing paper. The twelve platforms below all do this; they differ in how, for whom, and at what price. Three comparisons come up more than any other, so we broke them out: myCOI vs TrustLayer head to head, Certificial vs TrustLayer for the live data question, and the CertFocus alternative question, which is really a question about annual minimums. If you are weighing a managed service instead, the Docutrax alternative comparison covers that model. Two more head to heads buyers ask for are CertFocus vs myCOI, the two credentialed managed programs, and Jones vs myCOI for construction and real estate teams on Procore. When the two platforms in question take opposite approaches, credentialed reviewers versus a network driven platform, see CertFocus vs TrustLayer. Construction general contractors weighing a trade specialist should also read the Billy alternative comparison. Teams choosing between the two most established names should read Certificial vs myCOI, now that myCOI has rebranded to illumend. If you have not decided between buying software and outsourcing the work, start with COI tracking software vs a managed service. The other long-established full-service name is bcs, and the BCS alternative comparison covers where its analyst-led model wins and where it does not. For the insurance-industry-focused platform, see the SmartCompliance alternative comparison, and if you are weighing a full contractor prequalification network against plain certificate tracking, the Avetta alternative page draws that line. If your compliance program runs inside Procore or Viewpoint Vista, the PINS Advantage alternative comparison covers the only rival here with native integrations into both, and for an enterprise identity and supplier-risk suite where certificates are one module, see the EvidentID alternative and NetVendor alternative pages. Property managers whose vendors are being asked to pay an annual registration fee should read the Compliance Depot alternative comparison, which covers RealPage Vendor Credentialing and the vendor-paid model. Still working out what the category should do for you before comparing names? Start with what a COI tracking solution has to deliver, or walk through how to choose COI tracking software criterion by criterion.
Use these six capabilities as your checklist. A tool that only stores PDFs without verifying coverage is barely better than a shared folder.
Reads the insurer, policy numbers, coverage types, limits, dates and additional insured status off any ACORD 25, even scans and phone photos, with no manual entry.
Checks every certificate against the minimum limits and endorsements you require, and flags anything that falls short the moment it arrives.
Sends automated reminders before policies lapse, usually at 60, 30 and 15 days, so coverage never gaps and renewals are never late.
Keeps every certificate, requirement and vendor in one searchable place so you can answer "who is compliant?" in a single click.
Exports an audit-ready compliance report to Excel or PDF the moment a client, insurer or auditor asks for proof.
Groups certificates by vendor, project, property or trade and tracks each party's compliance status on its own.
COISoftware checks all six boxes and adds transparent pricing on top. It reads the same forms your agents send, from the ACORD 25 certificate of liability insurance to the broader certificate of insurance formats, then verifies coverage automatically. For the full feature picture, see our certificate of insurance management software and vendor insurance compliance pages. If you are weighing a specific incumbent, we also compare COISoftware head to head as a myCOI alternative, a TrustLayer alternative, a Jones COI tracking alternative and a Certificial alternative. Two less-covered names are worth a look if they are on your list: the enterprise suite comparison on our RiskPartner alternative page, and the outsourced construction model on our Paladin insurance certificate tracking alternative page.
Whichever platform you choose, the workflow is the same three steps.
Upload or forward your vendors' COIs. Modern tools read each ACORD 25 automatically, so nothing is retyped by hand.
Tip: Batch upload your whole vendor list to get a compliance baseline fast.
Define the minimum limits and required endorsements each vendor or project must carry. Every certificate is checked against these rules on upload and renewal.
Watch your compliance dashboard, let automated reminders chase renewals, and pull a report whenever you need proof.
An honest profile of each tool, including where it wins, so you can match the platform to how you actually work.
COISoftware is built for teams that want the automation of an enterprise platform without the enterprise sales process. It reads the ACORD 25 and other certificates with AI, checks every policy against the limits and endorsements you set, and sends renewal reminders at 60, 30 and 15 days. Pricing is transparent and monthly, with a free tier and no per-vendor minimums, so a property manager with 20 vendors and a contractor with 2,000 each pay only for what they use. Best for teams that want fast self-serve setup and clear pricing.
myCOI has tracked certificates since 2009 and pairs its illumend AI with a managed team of insurance experts who review certificates and chase vendors on your behalf. That service-heavy model suits mid-market compliance teams that would rather outsource the review work than run it in-house. Pricing is quote-based, and because part of the review is human-assisted, turnaround during busy renewal periods can vary. Best for mid-market teams wanting a done-for-you service.
Certificial takes a different approach from document-based tools by connecting to insurance agents' management systems through its Smart COI Network, so coverage is verified against live policy data rather than a static PDF, and vendors do not log in to upload anything. It is a strong fit for organizations that want real-time monitoring and can work within quote-based enterprise pricing. Best for teams that prioritize real-time policy verification.
TrustLayer is a collaborative risk-management platform that tracks certificates of insurance alongside W-9s, licenses and contracts, which makes it popular in construction and real estate where the COI is one of several records to manage. Like most tools it is document-centric, so mid-term policy changes surface at the next certificate cycle rather than instantly. Pricing is quote-based. Best for teams managing COIs plus other compliance documents.
SmartCompliance targets larger compliance programs and offers both self-service software and full-service options where its team handles certificate collection and review. It fits enterprises processing high certificate volume that want the flexibility to outsource part of the workload. Pricing is custom. Best for larger enterprise programs that need a service layer.
Jones focuses on real estate and property management, with a vendor-friendly workflow that removes the vendor login and emphasizes fast approvals. Property teams that onboard many vendors and tenants value the smoother vendor experience. Pricing is quote-based. Best for real estate and property management teams.
BCS leans full-service, collecting and reviewing certificates for construction firms and organizations with large subcontractor or vendor programs. It suits teams that prefer to hand off certificate processing entirely. Pricing is custom. Best for construction and large vendor or subcontractor programs.
CertFocus, from Vertikal RMS, is the one major platform that publishes per-vendor pricing, which makes it the easiest managed program to budget for before a sales call. Its self-service tier runs $6 to $8 per vendor per year with a $7,500 annual minimum, and its full-service tier $13 to $29 per vendor per year with a $10,000 minimum, staffed by CIC, CPCU, CISR and CRIS credentialed reviewers. Its Hawk-I engine reads the certificates. Best for enterprises that want credentialed insurance staff on review and a published price to plan around.
Avetta is not a pure COI tracker; it is a contractor prequalification and supply-chain risk network where insurance verification is one module alongside safety, training and an annual questionnaire. A certified insurance monitoring team validates supplier coverage against requirements. The model has the contractor pay to join the network, commonly $450 to $900 per year, with the hiring client paying a separate enterprise fee. Best for large supply chains that need full prequalification rather than certificate tracking alone; if you only need COIs tracked, a focused tool is lighter and cheaper.
Evident (EvidentID) is an enterprise identity and supplier risk suite where certificate verification is one module alongside identity, license and credential checks. It is one of only two platforms here that publish per-vendor pricing: $15 per vendor per year on Essential and $25 on Pro, with Enterprise quoted. That transparency makes it easy to model against your vendor count. Best for enterprises that want supplier identity and insurance verified in the same system. See the EvidentID alternative comparison.
PINS Advantage is the one platform here with native integrations into both Procore and Viewpoint Vista, which matters if your compliance program already lives inside a construction stack. It runs a self-service model with an agent portal so brokers can submit certificates directly. Pricing is quote only, structured across six volume bands. Best for construction and real estate teams standardized on Procore or Vista. See the PINS Advantage alternative comparison.
Compliance Depot is the long-established vendor credentialing program for multifamily property management, now branded RealPage Vendor Credentialing. It goes well beyond certificates: background checks, professional licenses, W-9s and financial screening, reviewed by their team, with a Credential Key profile that lets an approved vendor be cleared same-day across participating RealPage customers. The structural difference from every other platform on this list is who pays. Vendors buy their own annual enrollment, listed by property managers' 2025 onboarding pages at $99 a year on-site and $80 off-site, while the property manager price is quoted. Best for RealPage shops that want full credentialing handled and accept a vendor-paid model. See the Compliance Depot alternative comparison.
A few figures put the pricing and effort in context. Every number below is attributed to its source rather than invented, so you can cite and check it.
| Data point | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Self-service pricing, typical | About $3 to $10 per vendor per year | US market range across published and quoted plans |
| Full-service pricing, typical | About $10 to $30 per vendor per year | US market range across managed programs |
| Published per-vendor pricing | $6 to $8 self-service, $7,500 annual minimum | CertFocus, published by Vertikal RMS |
| Manual tracking staffing load | Roughly one full-time person per 1,500 certificates | Docutrax (Risk Toolbox) published figure |
| Largest verification networks | 517,000+ companies; learns from 400,000+ COIs per month | TrustLayer |
| Agency data network | 25,000+ insurance agencies connected | Certificial Smart COI Network |
| Fastest published verification SLA | 24-hour COI verification, 30,000+ vendor network | Jones |
The takeaway from the pricing rows: a self-service platform with published monthly plans and no per-vendor minimum is usually the lowest total cost until vendor volume is high enough that a managed service earns its premium, and the staffing figure is why. If one person can only keep about 1,500 certificates truly current by hand, software or a service is cheaper than the headcount somewhere between a few hundred and a few thousand vendors.
There is no single best COI tracking software for everyone. If you want a managed service and have budget for quote-based pricing, myCOI, BCS or SmartCompliance fit well. If you need real-time verification against live insurance data, look at Certificial. If you want AI-powered extraction, transparent monthly pricing, and a free way to start, that is exactly what COISoftware was built for. Try it on your own certificates using the uploader above before you commit to any platform. If you are still learning the category, the certificate of insurance software guide explains the types of COI software and what to look for.
The best COI tracking software depends on your needs: COISoftware for AI extraction and transparent pricing, myCOI for a managed service, Certificial for real-time policy data, and TrustLayer for tracking COIs alongside other documents. For most teams that want automation without a sales call, a tool with AI certificate reading, coverage verification and renewal reminders covers the essentials.
Across the market, self-service COI platforms run roughly $3 to $10 per vendor per year, full-service options $10 to $30, and enterprise deployments reach five and six figures annually. Most competitors quote custom pricing. COISoftware uses transparent monthly pricing with a free tier and no per-vendor minimums, so you can start at no cost and scale as you add certificates.
Good COI tracking software collects certificates from your vendors, reads the ACORD 25 automatically, verifies coverage against your required limits and endorsements, alerts you before policies expire, stores everything in one searchable place, and exports an audit-ready compliance report. If a tool only stores PDFs without verifying coverage, it is barely better than a folder.
COISoftware offers a free plan so you can upload certificates and see the AI extraction and verification before paying. Most established platforms like myCOI and Certificial are quote-based with no free tier. Free spreadsheet templates exist, but they only store data; they cannot read a certificate or send a renewal reminder.
It depends on what you value. myCOI offers a managed expert team, Certificial verifies against live insurance data with no vendor login, and TrustLayer tracks COIs alongside W-9s and contracts. All three are quote-based. If you want the same automation with transparent pricing and a free way to start, compare them to COISoftware first.
Yes. Small businesses tracking even 10 to 20 vendors benefit from automated verification and renewal reminders, because a single lapsed policy can become an uninsured claim. COISoftware has no per-vendor minimum and a free tier, so small teams are not forced into enterprise pricing to get the basics.
A spreadsheet works for a handful of vendors, but it cannot read a certificate, check limits against your requirements, or email you before a policy expires. Most teams outgrow Excel past 15 to 20 vendors, when manual entry errors and missed renewals start creating real coverage gaps. Software automates the parts a spreadsheet leaves to you.
The established certificate of insurance tracking companies include COISoftware, myCOI (now illumend), Certificial, TrustLayer, CertFocus, SmartCompliance, Jones and BCS, plus prequalification networks like Avetta that verify insurance as one part of a broader program. They split into self-service software you run yourself and full-service providers whose analysts do the work. Match the model to your team first, then compare extraction accuracy on your own certificates.
Yes. Full-service certificate of insurance tracking companies like myCOI, BCS and SmartCompliance collect, review and chase certificates on your behalf, priced by custom quote. Self-service software like COISoftware does the same reading and verification with AI so your team stays in control, with transparent pricing and a free tier. Choose a managed service if you want to outsource the work, or software if you want fast automation you run yourself.
See how COISoftware compares to myCOI on pricing, setup and features.
Read ACORD 25 data, verify coverage and track every COI expiration.
Collect, verify and track vendor and subcontractor COIs in one place.
Self-service COI tracking compared to NetVendor's managed program.
Focused COI tracking compared to an enterprise vendor due-diligence suite.
Start tracking vendor certificates of insurance and never miss an expiration.
USD
per month
billed as
$288 yearly
Choose speed vs accuracy when extracting
| Base AI Faster | 2,500 pages |
| Pro AI Best accuracy | 500 pages |
Scale COI compliance across your whole team with automated reminders.
USD
per month
billed as
$888 yearly
Choose speed vs accuracy when extracting
| Base AI Faster | 10,000 pages |
| Pro AI Best accuracy | 2,000 pages |
Enterprise‑grade COI tracking, security, and controls.
USD
per month
billed as
$ yearly
Choose speed vs accuracy when extracting
| Base AI Faster | pages |
| Pro AI Best accuracy | pages |
Custom workflows and deployment for AI automation at scale
